Disney’s string of live-action remakes continues to grab headlines and spark social media debates—but are they actually winning over American audiences? A new report from streaming guide JustWatch suggests that while curiosity around these modern reboots remains high, nostalgia and love for the original animated classics still reign supreme.
Live-Action Clicks, But Classic Love
The latest JustWatch data reveals a telling trend: live-action versions like The Little Mermaid (2023) and Snow White (2025) attract strong viewer interest, but they’re falling short in one key area—user ratings. Across the board, original animated versions outperform their live-action counterparts by over 60% in average user approval.
For instance, Snow White (2025) saw decent popularity but tanked with a user rating of only 31%, compared to the beloved 1937 animated version with a solid 91%. Similarly, while The Little Mermaid (2023) had the highest popularity score of any remake, it still trailed the 1989 classic, which boasts a stellar 95% approval rating.
Nostalgia Wins Again
“Trying to outdo a beloved classic is always a tough challenge,” said Mike Pearce, analyst at JustWatch. “What we’re seeing is that while viewers are curious enough to check out the remakes, their emotional loyalty lies with the originals.”
The data supports this. Films like Beauty and the Beast (1991), Aladdin (1992), and The Little Mermaid (1989) continue to dominate in user ratings—despite receiving fewer clicks than their live-action reboots.
Which Remakes Come Close?
Not all live-action films are missing the mark. Some have managed to strike a balance between modern updates and fan approval. Notably:
- Cinderella (2015): 88% rating
- Beauty and the Beast (2017): 88% rating
- Aladdin (2019): 86% rating
These films stand out as the most successful at capturing the magic of their animated roots while introducing new elements that didn’t alienate longtime fans.
The Verdict: Curiosity, Not Commitment
Ultimately, the report paints a clear picture: Americans are eager to explore Disney’s new takes, but they’re not necessarily ready to trade in their VHS (or Disney+) favorites.
So, while Disney’s remakes may be box-office bait and algorithm boosters, it’s the hand-drawn heritage of the originals that continues to win hearts and hold their place in pop culture.
Want to see how your favorite Disney remake stacks up?
Visit JustWatch and explore user ratings, streaming platforms, and more.
You must be logged in to post a comment.